Discussions on Geographical Divination (Dili Bianhuo)

Ma Taiqing's Qing-dynasty catechism on fengshui, weighing form and Three-Element theory while refuting popular Sanhe errors.

Original pages
58 pages
Preview
6 pages
Category
Feng Shui
Period
Unknown
Added
2026年11月21日
Updated
2026年11月21日

Reading guide

Content guide

Overview

Dili Bianhuo is a question-and-answer treatise on fengshui by the Qing scholar Ma Taiqing. In his preface Ma recounts his early fascination with geomantic literature, his dissatisfaction with Sanhe and auxiliary-star methods, and his eventual discipleship under Li Zhenyu in Beijing, after which he verified numerous old graves. The main text proceeds through thirteen questions. The opening exchanges establish that form (xingshi) is the body and liqi the function, and mock vulgar masters who name every hill after lions, elephants or turtles. Later questions assess classical texts, praising Yang Junsong's Dragon Classics and Jiang Dahong's Dili Bianzheng and Tianyuan Wuge as authentic, while dismissing Sanhe dragon-water-direction formulas as fixed dead patterns. Ma argues that form governs birth and liqi governs prosperity, and explains how civil-examination success depends on Wenchang and Kuixing positions. Compact and polemical, the book is a key source for studying the Sanhe-Sanyuan debate in Qing fengshui.

Contents

Preface: Ma's training and teachers

Q1: Form as the primary basis

Q2-3: Critiquing vulgar naming and 'eye'

Q4: Form texts vs. liqi texts

Q5: Refuting Sanhe fixed patterns

Q6-10: Form, liqi and fortune

Q11-13: True liqi and source texts

Key Points

Uses a Q&A format to argue form is substance and liqi is application.

Rejects Sanhe dragon-water-direction formulas as fixed dead patterns.

Endorses Jiang Dahong's Dili Bianzheng and Tianyuan Wuge as authentic Sanyuan teaching.

Links descendants, longevity, wealth and examination success to landscape features and Wenchang positions.

About these notes: These notes are based on the first 6 pages, contents and publicly available material of Discussions on Geographical Divination (Dili Bianhuo). Interpretations may still be wrong; corrections are welcome.
PAGES

Page preview

5 pages · Click to enlarge
RELATED
More in Feng Shui
WeChat